El Maya Restaurant

  • This is our default place and has been for 3-4 years. The food is consistently above average.
    Personally very attentive waitstaff is just as
    important as good food. Tasty Salsa, bean dip and homemade tortilla chips (yes they are still
    hot when you get them) are served almost before
    we get to the table. Staff know us due to frequent visits however I also pay attention to how
    other guests are treated and if a glass gets near
    empty they are there doing refills, checking at a reasonable interval though not pesky if having
    a conversation. I would definitely recommend
    this place to anyone looking for good Mexican food. For a family of 4 typically our bill comes
    to $42-47 with sodas. Magaritas are good and similar
    in price to other restaurants in the area.

    • Matthew J
  • My wife and I found this place a few years ago. We frequent this place more than any other place
    in town. Food is authentic, service is always
    fast and friendly. Prices are affordable. Our bill is usually $22-25, minus tip. They have
    combos that are less expensive. Hearty meals for a fair price.
    We come here for our special occasions.

    • Sportman1968
  • Takeout review: We stopped after running errands and wanted to take the food home. The
    greeter/host was super friendly, cleared a spot at the bar for us to
    site while we looked through the menus and waited for our food. The menu is quite extensive, but
    easily divided/marked so you can find what you want fairly easily.
    It only took about 10 minutes for the food to be made, and the host put some extra chips and
    salsa in the bag for us.

    Bonus: they have horchata, which is hard to find in Green Bay, and it’s good. We all enjoyed our
    food as well; I had the chicken flautas and they were cooked well.

    Overall, great takeout option, and I definitely plan to go back for a sit down meal when I’m
    back in town!

    • Kate H.
  • Great food, fast, and great service as always.
    Very inexpensive as well!!
    As a family we love to eat Mexican. My daughters for years have referred to this restaurant as
    “THE Mexican Restaurant” because it is everyone’s favorite.
    My husband and co workers come here frequently for lunch as well. Food is always fantastic and
    service is very speedy.
    Chile verde is great. My girls love the fajita taco salads in a perfect size mini shell for
    them. My favorite is the fajita taco salad.
    Queso is tasty too.
    Their chips, salsa, and bean dip are complimentary and always tasty!
    I love getting a margarita and my girls get frozen lemonade.
    Who would have thought that a little restaurant connected to a gas station would be this

    • Alyssa S.
  • To find decent Mexican food this far north is a blessing.
    I’ve eaten here three times, each time has generated a welcome surprise.
    The owner and waitress are very good. They understand customer service and quality food.
    I had the grilled chicken margarita. Grilled chicken breast smothered with cheese.
    Tons of choices.

    • Alyssa S.