This week, New York City restaurant hostess Julia Carolan went viral on TikTok for rating her experiences serving different celebrities. In the initial video, which has more than 13 million views, Carolan rated Gigi and Bella Hadid (10/10), Cameron Dallas (4/10), and even called Kylie Jenner out for leaving a $20 tip on a $500 bill, saying, "Do with that information what you will" (2/10).
But it was her assessment of Hailey Bieber that made the celebrity herself take notice. In the video, Carolan said of the model, "This is gonna be controversial. I've met her a handful of times and every time she was not nice." She added, "I really wanna like her, but I have to give her like a 3.5 out of 10. Sorry." That prompted Bieber to apologize to Carolan in the comments section, writing, “Just came across this video, and wanted to say sorry if I’ve ever given you bad vibes or a bad attitude. That’s not ever my intention!”
After the breakout success of her first video, Carolan bestowed us with a part two. In that video, she scored Beyoncé a 10/10 (naturally) and referred to Drake & Josh star Josh Peck as the "nicest celebrity" she's met. As for the KarJenners, they didn't fair much better in this installment. Carolan revealed that Kendall Jenner was "pretty cold towards staff" and typically had "someone speak for her" instead of directly interacting with employees. "I'm going to give her the benefit of the doubt and say she's just shy," the user concluded, rating her a 4/10.
This content is imported from Tiktok. You may be able to find the same content in another format, or you may be able to find more information, at their web site.
So far, no other celebrities have publicly apologized to Carolan. But they may think twice before giving a bad impression or unsavory tip at their next brunch outing.
Savannah Walsh is an Editorial Fellow at ELLE.com.