Holiday Themed Restaurants To Visit in New York City | Stroller in the City

The holidays are here and I seriously couldn’t be any happier. I talk a big game about Fall, but the holiday season makes it hard to not love both just as much. New York City is truly so magical this time of year.  Everywhere you look businesses have decorated. Boutiques, deli’s, restaurants, etc… Year round New Yorker’s mostly socialize in restaurants and/or bars, and the holidays are no exception.

The beautiful lights and ribbons get to me. I can’t help but feel so excited for the holidays when I see these decorations, especially in the restaurants I know and love so much! Now that we’re getting back to a more normal way of life in the city, we are going out to eat at restaurants again and I have to tell you- it feels great! I have missed it so very much.

I love the magical feeling the city gives at this time of the year. My kids love to see the festive decor all over the city and it’s way more fun to go to restaurants that get into the holiday spirit and make you feel so welcome there with their festive decorations. I originally had 10 on my list, but it just felt like there were so many choices, and I didn’t want to leave any great ones out, so I added a handful more. Here’s my full list I have put together of my favorite restaurants to gather with family and friends during the holiday season for that extra special festive feel.

Rolfs Christmas Lights 2

There is absolutely nothing quite like Rolf’s! This German restaurant is fully decorated for Christmas all year long. Yes, all year long. They don’t take any of the festive decor down. You can expect a traditional German menu full of schnitzel, spaetzle, bratwurst, potato pancakes, and more. Evenings get busy and the bar are gets lively but this is definitely the most festive restaurant in NYC.

Midtown Restaurant Interior 1400x700 1

The Black Tap in Midtown is the perfect spot to grab a bite to eat after checking out the magical Rockefeller Christmas Tree! They have a brand new cocktail menu you won’t want to miss! Black Tap is famous for their milkshakes though, and it’s easy to see why, they are fully loaded with the yummiest sweets! This spot is also kid friendly!

IMG 9444

This Seaport restaurant is much more than just their amazing pizza options. They have a full menu of fantastic dishes to choose from! What I love about them, is that they have a ton of outdoor space, if it makes you feel more comfortable to sit outside at this time. They even have those adorable little house/igloo setup if you want! I think they do a great job at decorating for the holidays, as well! I love these reindeer!

IMG 9586

This place is fantastic! If you’re looking for a festive restaurant that is kid friendly, look no further! They are famous for their frozen hot chocolate, I’m not kidding when I say it’s the best thing in the world! It comes in a ton of different flavors, too. Food-wise they have everything you can imagine. Get a reservation today!


Balthazar is a true New York City staple. The epitome of a big French bistro with red leather booths, martini’s, steak frites, and delicious sweets! Whether you visit for breakfast for dinner you’re bound to have a true NYC experience at Balthazar. They also have an adjacent bakery if you just want a quick coffee and/or  baked good while on the go.

2014 12 10 petestavern thumb

One of NYC’s oldest bars, Pete’s Tavern is a local favorite. Pete’s was founded in 1864 and has never shut its doors since. Serving a mostly Italian American menu that its regulars keep coming back for. As soon as you walk in you notice the wall filled with old photos through its decades in service and the many celebrities who have walked through its doors. Pete’s is a NYC landmark definitely worth visiting during the holiday season.

NYC’s most delicious seasonal restaurant. Menu  and the decor is totally based on the current season.  With American fare, bottomless brunch, exquisite rotating decor, and an amazing location this is a definite holiday must! I love the concept of changing not just the menu but also the decor as the seasons change. Definitely a unique and fun concept that keeps our family going back.

2018 11 november flatiron serra alpina 16 featured

How could I resist a gorgeous indoor rooftop with a huge Italian market downstairs? I absolutely love this winter wonderland at Eataly Flatiron during the holidays. Its the perfect place to meet a girlfriend for a festive holiday lunch. I always grab some market necessities at the market downstairs on my way out. Because the restaurant uses all fresh imported ingredients from Italy the menu is always delicious and like taking a trip to Italy itself. Its also an incredibly kid friendly restaurant and high on my families favorites list.

Screen Shot 2019 11 18 at 15.32.16

I love a delicious French menu full of escargot, cheese, steak frites, etc…. Lafayette never disappoints for my French cravings. Similar to Paris and Parisians, theres an elegance to the restaurant and its aesthetic. As soon as you walk in, it feels grand and special and very festive for the holidays. With a sommelier on staff don’t hesitate to ask all your wine questions. They have one of my favorite bakeries in the city so I always make sure to grab a few baked goodies for the next day.

IMG 9442

This East Village bar goes all out for the holidays! The drinks are festive and delicious, but don’t let them fool you. The food is just as good! They have great burger and American food options. This is a great place to go for a casual vibe with magical decor!


This grand bar at the Beekman Tower is a gorgeous space all year round but is extra special during the holidays. It transforms into a snow globe winter wonderland. Located on the top floor of the hotel, Ophelia is an indoor rooftop bar specializing in mixology and specialty cocktails. Perfect to warm up on a cold winter night. Ophelia is at the top of my list for the ultimate holiday beverage.

IMG 0046

This Midtown classic establishment goes all out for the holidays! It’s part of a hotel that has a ton of great, different room options whether it’s for a family stay, with friends or a solo trip! They are open pretty late, especially on the weekends, so if you’re looking for a later option to go out, this is your spot! And it’s in Midtown, so there are a ton of sights around to visit if you’re in town! You can’t beat that view, either!

130a8534 30 ps2 1572900988

What is actually better than champagne and the holidays? Well the people at Veuve Clicquot totally agree! They have partnered with the very popular NYC rooftop bar Mr. Purple to bring New Yorkers the ultimate holiday bar pop up. Guests can be found sipping champagne in life size snow globe/ igloo like spaces. Don’t forget to order the fondue or to maybe indulge in a spike hot chocolate. This is the most Instagram worthy holiday space of the season!

IMG 9437

This classic Central Park West spot is stunning this time of year! They bring in a huge Christmas tree every year and put it underneath all the lights outside! It really is a beautiful view while you eat and drink. This is a great spot to go to if you’re visiting, as it is near Central Park and they have a whole Christmas tree there! And check out the elves! It’s decorated so well and makes the space feel truly magical.


Blog Lucky Strike Holiday 2015 Pic 1 copy

Lucky Strike is another old school NYC classic adored by locals. Lucky Strikes definitely knows how to decorate for the festive season. The less elevated little brother to Balthazar and Pastis, Lucky Strike is a great option for a more casual evening. Regulars swear by the French onion soup and all the brunch options. With Happy Hour everyday of the week this is a wonderful no fuss restaurant perfect for a holiday catch up with a friend.

IMG 9440

This spot has a more winter decor feeling than holiday, per say, but it still feels super festive! I love all the twinkly lights and greenery, it makes the space feel incredibly homey and welcoming in the winter. This terrace always has the best decorations, though! They do great florals in the summer. It’s a very instagrammable place to eat and drink! Look at those lights on the ceiling!

PNG image

City Winery has revamped its menu for the winter and to say I’m excited to try it, would be an understatement! With new items like mission fig pizza, seared scallops, hot honey pizza, raspberry chipotle wings and so much more, you’re sure to be fully satisfied! Not to mention, the wine selection is some of the very best! You’ve gotta check them out!

one if by land two if by sea

This is definitely one of the more refined options on my list. Located in a landmarked Greenwich Village carriage house this space is so unique its often used for weddings. With a prefixed menu and a full two story tree, its a must for a formal family holiday meal or a romantic meal with a sweet someone special.

This post was originally published on November 19th, 2019.

For more holiday themed posts, click here!